Skip to content

City board authorizes request for new housing proposals on Unity church lot

Wauwatosa's Community Development Authority bought the property at 1717 N. 73rd St. in June and plans to demolish the building for redevelopment.

City board authorizes request for new housing proposals on Unity church lot
Unity of Milwaukee has occupied the building on the northwest corner of 73rd Street and Milwaukee Avenue since 1973. Photo by Sam Paulsen for Tosa Forward News.

Wanted: A developer willing and able to turn a small but prominent corner lot on the edge of Tosa Village into new housing units.

Wauwatosa's Community Development Authority, which purchased 1717 N. 73rd St. in June from the Unity congregation, voted on Nov. 12 to pursue a request for proposals in search of a developer interested in buying and transforming the property. The .84-acre parcel allows for a maximum of 12 units under the property's mixed residential zoning.

Wauwatosa Development Director Nate Piotrowski told the CDA, during its online meeting on Zoom, that the request for proposals could be posted as soon as this month, with submissions due by February. That would give the CDA time to review the proposals and possibly accept one before Unity church and its tenant, Children's Workshop, are required to move out at the end of May 2027.

The city then would demolish the building to clear the property for resale and a housing redevelopment up to 4,000 square feet under the property's zoning. Preference will be given to "missing middle housing," such as townhouses, duplexes and small multi-family buildings.